Men Belong To A Higher Level Than Women—They Are Better Than Women
While our Gurus assure us that men and women are equal, the Qur’an declares to us
in Chapter 2:22 that men are a degree above women. It also says in Chapter 4:34:
"Men are in charge of women because Allah has made the one of them excel the
Of course, we do not believe that God says that
men surpass women. If the reader wonders what these Qur’anic verses mean and why
Islam says that men are a degree above women and they are better than them, we
would like to refer him to the answer of the Muslim scholars.
The Ancient Scholars
On page 79, the Jalalan says:
"Men have been given authority over women to discipline and control them by
the merits of knowledge, intelligence and custody, etc., which God bestowed on
some over others."
In his commentary, page 111, the Baydawi says:
"God preferred man over woman, and the reason for the bestowing of this verse
(4:34) is a well-known episode which says that a man from the helpers beat his
wife, whose name was Habiba, the daughter of Zayd. Her father took her to the
apostle of God (to complain). Muhammad said: "Let us punish him." But God sent
down this verse 4:34. The woman returned home without having her husband
punished. Muhammad said: ‘I intended to do something (that is, to punish the
man), but God willed otherwise, and what God wills is better.’"
This famous incident was the reason God sent down this verse which prefers men to
women and prohibits the retribution of men if they abuse their wives. This episode
is mentioned also in the commentary of the Jalalan (page 69) as well as in the
suyuti’s book, "Reasons for Sending the Verses From God" (Asbab al-Nuzul, p.75).
Suyuti tells us that the women said to Muhammad:
"My husband beat me and left some marks on my face. In spite of that, the man
was not punished though Muhammad wanted to do so but the just God, the God of
equality, declined and did not allow Muhammad to punish the man for abusing his
What a compassionate God who sympathizes with relentless men! Is this the God who
honors women? This God revealed a verse which confirms that men are better than
women and above them by one degree, and that they have the right to discipline
them. However, what concerns us here is to stress the point that the Qur’an says
that men are a degree above women and better than them.
The Contemporary Scholars
It is sufficient here to quote the Azher scholars: Mrs. Iman Kamil corresponded with
the Azhar scholars and Sheikhs inquiring about this critical subject in order to
comprehend the meaning of the verse under discussion (4:34). The following is her
question and the answer she received as they were published in "Liwa al-Islamic"
("The Islamic Banner")in its issue of July 4, 1985, page 6. The question was:
"What is the interpretation of the Qur’anic verse: ‘Men are the managers of the
affairs of women for that God preferred in bounty one of them over another?"’
The answer of the Azhar scholars was:
"Abu al-Hasan al-Basri said: ‘A woman came to the prophet complaining against
her husband, who slapped her face. The apostle of God said: "(He must be)
punished." But God sent down this verse, and the woman returned home
empty-handed.’ The meaning of his saying: ‘Manager’ is that a man is the
woman’s lord and her disciplinarian whenever she disobeys him. God has
explained that the reason for this lordship is that men excel women."
What more can be said after this issue has become so obvious? The reader can easily
discern if God is the one who composed it to please the powerful men among his
It is obvious from the comment of the ancient scholars as
well as the Azhar scholars that Islam does not penalize a man when he abuses his
wife because men are superior to women! The story is well known, and it was cited
by all the Muslim scholars without exception.
Taken from http://answering-islam.org/BehindVeil/btv3.html#CH3 (Note: We do not necessarily endorse this site or its views.)